Shared Workspace в Smarteam

[ExtraRight 2]

На ибм-овском сайте техподдержки в комментах к юзерскому запросу, претендовавшему на баг, нашли такие строки:

SMARTEAM Shared Workspace is not a functionality

that should be promoted for collaboration on top of

CATIA.

SMARTEAM CATIA Integration pushes collaboration

thru into-vault and out-of-vault operations, allowing

designers to synchronize their design on demand

and in a robust way. Functionalities such as Check-

Out-on-the-fly, Global Refresh, and Replace With

Selected Revision promote design collaboration.

SMARTEAM CATIA Integration architecture was not

designed to support the new behavior introduced

by SMARTEAM Shared Workspace product.

Managing this new behavior, would require a

complete redesign of SMARTEAM CATIA Integration

code.

Внимание, вопрос: для какого CAD писалась эта технология? Для SolidWorks?

[green_fx 0]

Для CATIA V5

[ExtraRight 2]

green_fx , у тебя как с английским?

Английским по белому же написано:

SMARTEAM Shared Workspace - это не та функциональность, которую следовало бы внедрять для оптимальной совместной работы с CATIA.

Первоисточник: <noindex>http://www-1.ibm.com/support/docview.wss?r...f-8〈=en</noindex>

Полный текст:

HD58843: STCAI : IN SHARED WORKSPACE, PROBLEM DURING CHECK OUT OPERATION

APAR status

Closed as suggestion for future release.

Error description

STCAI : In Shared Workspace, problem during

check out operation

CATIA Smarteam Integration Issue reproducible

with SmDemo and a Shared Workspace.

Problem description

1. Create Shared Workspace.

2. In Smarteam Tools/Switch workspace, select the

new createed Shared workspace where the user is

the Integrator.

3. In CATIA, Integrator creates a CATPart.

4. Save in Smarteam Integration.

5. Check-in. (the Part is still in CATIA session).

6. In CATIA, Check out the loaded Part just

checked In in step 5.

The CATIA Part changes its current status to not

latest while the status must be Checked-out.

This problem only happens in Shared workspace.

.

Local fix

Problem summary

Problem conclusion

Temporary fix

Comments

THIS APAR IS CONSIDERED AS A SUGGESTION

FOR IMPROVEMENT WHICH CANNOT BE

INCORPORATED IN CATIA VERSION 5 RELEASE 18.

PLEASE CONTACT YOUR SUPPORT DEPARTMENT IN

ORDER TO OPEN A REQUIREMENT FORM.

SMARTEAM Shared Workspace has introduced new

rules for the management of documents:

- files are located in a shared area accessible by

mutliple users

- authorizations are not only based on SMARTEAM

life-cycle states but also on ownership

These new rules have a negative impact on CATIA

and CAI:

- CATIA has a "partial loading" mechanism. This

mechanism allow to load into memory the part of

the document which is required by CATIA; the

remaining part being automatically loaded when

requested by the CATIA session. This mechanism

require that the file on disk does not get changed

once it has been "partially" loaded in the CATIA

session

- CAI use SMARTEAM life-cycle states for the

definition of the user authorizations. Basically, user

can modify a document if it is in "checked-out"

state. This life-cycle state is reflected by

a "read&write" access to the file in the user "work"

folder. This rule is not respected by SMARTEAM

Shared Workspace: even if a document is

in "checked-out" state, it may be "read-only" for

the user in case he did not get "ownership"

Conclusion

SMARTEAM Shared Workspace is not a functionality

that should be promoted for collaboration on top of

CATIA.

SMARTEAM CATIA Integration pushes collaboration

thru into-vault and out-of-vault operations, allowing

designers to synchronize their design on demand

and in a robust way. Functionalities such as Check-

Out-on-the-fly, Global Refresh, and Replace With

Selected Revision promote design collaboration.

SMARTEAM CATIA Integration architecture was not

designed to support the new behavior introduced

by SMARTEAM Shared Workspace product.

Managing this new behavior, would require a

complete redesign of SMARTEAM CATIA Integration

code.

[capitaine 0]

Дим, ну судя по тому, что до 10-го релиза (вроде как) все презентации Смартима были на примере работы его с Solid Works... ну ты понял))

а из Дассо товарищ тебе и не ответит что есть на самом деле. статус не позволяет )

[green_fx 0]

2 ExtraRight

ладно тебе придираться